Apple Rutabaga Soup


            About two years ago, the “hungry” hubby and I attended an eight-course dinner in honor of Patrick O’ Connell, chef proprietor of the “Inn at Little Washington”. The idea was that eight local chefs were each to prepare a dish from Patrick’s new book “Refined American Cuisine”.  Quite daunting if you ask me with the great man himself seated right there to taste each rendition of his recipes. This was the same night I met J, a lady of great taste in haute cuisine. She was a regular at “The Inn at Little Washington” so she was quite familiar with the menu offering and would know immediately if the recipe interpretations were off. One item on the menu that I remember quite well is the Apple Rutabaga soup. It was a soup chock full of flavor but so smooth and refined that you wondered how it could be infused with so much complexity.

Well to start with, I have never heard of rutabaga but I soon found out that it is very similar to the turnip. It is relatively tasteless eaten as is but according to Patrick O’ Connell, the flavor is brought about by maple syrup!

            The first time the “hungry” hubby and I attempted making this soup, it did not turn out the way we had it at that fateful dinner. We did not know whether to include the broth in the puree or leave it out. We finally determined that we do need the broth since we could not strain the puree without it. We had quite a giggle after that; the cluelessness of it all! My second attempt this time around was more a success; even I was surprised. This time it was deliciously rich without diminishing gratification due to increasing satiety.

¼ lb (1 stick) butter (113gm)

1 cup roughly chopped onion (230gm)

1 cup peeled, cored and roughly chopped Granny Smith apple (230gm)

1 cup peeled and roughly chopped rutabaga (230gm)

1 cup peeled, seeded, and roughly chopped butternut squash (230gm)

1 cup peeled and roughly chopped carrots (230gm)

1 cup peeled and roughly chopped sweet potato (230gm)

1 quart good chicken stock (1 lt)

2 cups heavy cream (480ml)

¼ cup maple syrup (60ml)

Salt and cayenne pepper to taste

In a large saucepan over medium-high heat, melt the butter. Add the onions, apple, rutabaga, squash, carrots, and sweet potato and cook, stirring occasionally, until the onions are translucent.

Add the chicken stock, and bring to a boil. Simmer for 20 to 25 minutes or until all of the vegetables are cooked through and tender.

Puree the vegetables in a blender or food processor. Strain through a fine mesh sieve into the same pot you used to cook the vegetables. Add the cream, maple syrup, salt, and cayenne pepper.

Return the pot to the stove, bring the soup to a simmer, and serve.


            This recipe is very flexible, you do not have to exactly measure one cup each. Those are just guidelines. Before you add the syrup, salt and cayenne pepper taste the strained puree and adjust your seasonings accordingly. Also, I did not use the full 2 cups of heavy cream, the best thing to do is to whisk it in slowly and as you attain the consistency and color you like, stop.

I pureed the vegetable in 3 batches. Do not attempt to put it all in your food processor (unless you have one of those huge commercial ones) or you will end up with a big mess on your hands. I still ended up with a big mess since I could not determine which sieve to use. I eventually settled on a very fine mesh chinois. It is important to puree the vegetables very well by letting the food processor run for approximately 30 seconds for each batch. Have patience straining it through the chinois. Every drop is “liquid autumn”!

6 thoughts on “Apple Rutabaga Soup

  1. That soup looks silky smooth and beautiful! I love autumn soups, although my most recent attempt was just a bit thin. I'll have to try this recipe – I like the idea of the different sweet fruits and vegetables accented by the earthier tastes and the maple.

  2. Thank you very much for the recipe. Rutabagas, when cooked and mashed have a distinctive, pleasantly bitter taste that I love. Unlike turnips which can become very sweet when turned into soup, rutabagas retain an assertive, earthy edge when boiled. Unfortunately, one of the changes I made in modifying the fat content of this recipe was replacing 1/3 of the liquid (the cream) with cider which is a lot sweeter than a tart Granny Smith apple. I cut back on the number of sweet vegetables and decreased the grams of those I retained while increasing the grams of rutabagas. Result? The pureed soup tasted like a velvety carrot soup with nary a trace of rutabaga. The cayenne and maple syrup do play important roles, the kick of the pepper being especially welcome. I used only a drop of the latter because the soup was too sweet for my taste, but it still altered the flavor nicely. I ended up squeezing a wedge of Meyer lemon over my bowl to cut the uniformly sweet factor. Good idea. Of course, you can't fault a recipe when you change it so drastically, so I won't. I will have to try it again without the cider and with even more rutabaga. I'd add celery, sacrificing some of the carrot, too. You can still taste the butter when 5 T are cut.

  3. Elizabeth, I do find that the recommended cream is a too much for me also. I put a note to use less so you are fine in cutting the cream. The recipe is fun to play with and it does taste pretty sweet in the end…I think the cream would cut the sweetness down so there is that tradeoff. Keep me posted with your experiments!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s