2 days to apple pie …

Apple pie is an Old-fashioned, All-american favorite

What?! An apple pie that takes 2 days to make? Who’s crazy enough to do that? Well, Michel Richard for one and uhm…me. What can I say? I’m a sucker for this particular baked treat. When yet another apple pie recipe promises to be the best one and has a technique I’ve never tried, I get “sucked” in. (Though 2 days is an exaggeration and most of the time spent is waiting.)

The problem with fruit pies is the soggy bottom crust that naturally occurs when fruit juices start soaking up the prized bottom layer that supposedly supports the pie. I have successfully addressed this issue before by letting the apples macerate with the sugar and by boiling the juices down further. Additionally, I fill the apple pie and then refrigerate it until the fruit-mixture is well-chilled. This guarantees that the crust cooks first before the filling does, thus assuring a firmer crust.

So why, when a more complex recipe comes along, do I even want to try it?


Which killed the cat, if I remember.

I will state off the bat that I was not impressed with the result. I was rebelling with the recipe starting with the 12 fuji apples it required (though I think it was partly the thought of skinning 12 apples), not to mention that it was quartered and not sliced thinner than what I am used to. I really wonder how small were the apples used to test the recipes. Another glaring issue I saw was the low temperature used to cook the pie.

Par-baked crust filed with chunky apples

I have utmost respect for Monsieur Richard, because dining at his restaurant, Citronelle, has been one of the few brilliant fine dining experiences I savor unto this day.

He is a great storyteller in his new dessert book, “Sweet Magic”, which I enjoyed reading cover to cover on one chilly night while sipping a steamy cup of chocolat chaud.

I was disappointed in my execution of this recipe and realized I have a disconnect with the great maestro of whimsical cuisine.

My bottom crust, despite being par-baked, tasted like plain “floury” dough. I had quite the amount of leftover apples and I did cut thinner to lessen the chunkiness. The taste of the filling was good – not too sweet- but failed to justify the time spent to make the entire pie. I do not know how to describe the top crust whether it was too flaky or too delicate for a robust and homey dessert like apple pie.

Maybe one of you will have better luck. Please let me know.

World’s Flakiest Apple Pie

from “Sweet Magic” by Michel Richard

Day 1

2 cups (4 sticks) unsalted butter, frozen and cut into 1/2-inch cubes
1 cup pastry flour

Day 2

3 cups pastry flour
1/4 cup granulated sugar
1 teaspoon salt
About 3/4 cup ice water


12 Fuji apples, peeled, cored, and cut into quarters
1 cup packed brown sugar
1/4 cup cornstarch
1 tablespoon cinnamon
1 teaspoon salt
1/4 teaspoon apple juice

1 egg, beaten with fork
1/4 cup sliced almonds
Powdered sugar for dusting

The day before you plan to serve the pie, put the frozen butter cubes into a food processor and pulse for 1 minute.
Add the flour and continue pulsing until tiny balls form. Transfer the mixture to a bowl, cover with plastic wrap, and freeze overnight.
The next day, return the mixture to the food processor bowl. Add the flour, sugar, and salt, and pulse, adding the ice water 1 tablespoon at a time, very slowly. When the mixture just starts binding, you may not need all the water, turn the dough out onto a lightly floured work surface and finish forming it into a ball by hand. Wrap the dough in plastic and refrigerate for a few hours.

Preheat the oven to 325 degrees.
To make the filling, combine all the ingredients in a large bowl, stirring until the apples are well coated. Pour the mixture into a large glass or ceramic baking dish and bake for 45 minutes, stirring every 15 minutes. Let cool. Leave the oven on.
Meanwhile, prepare the pie shell by buttering a 9-inch pie plate. Unwrap the dough, cut it in half, then rewrap and return one piece to the refrigerator.
Roll out the other half to form an 11-inch round 1/4 inch thick. Gently wrap the rolled dough around the rolling pin, move the pie plate under the pin, and unroll the dough into the plate. Gently but firmly press the crust into place, and use a knife to cut the excess around the outer edge of the pie plate. Make sure you leave dough on top of the pie plate to edge. Freeze shell for 20 minutes.

Roll the remaining dough into another 11-inch round 1/4 inch thick. Make sure it will fit over the top of the pie with a little excess hanging off the sides. Rewrap it and return it to the refrigerator to rest.
Line the inside of the pie shell with parchment paper. Fill it with dry beans or pie weights and bake it for 45 minutes. Remove the weights and parchment and allow the crust to cool on the counter.
Spoon the cooled apple filling into the par-baked piecrust. Brush the beaten egg along the edges of the crust. Lay the top crust over the apples and gently apply pressure to the edges to form a seal. Cut off any excess dough from the sides of the pie plate using knife or scissors. Brush the remaining egg wash onto the top crust. With a knife or cookie cutter, make 1/4 to 1/2 inch hole in the center of the top crust. Sprinkle the sliced almonds on top of the piecrust and finish with a little powdered sugar.

 Cooking notes:

  •  As I’ve said in the recipe head notes, I couldn’t understand why the temperature was so low. I suspect that was a mistake, for even if I let my apples cook longer both in the initial bake time and in the pie, they remained slightly firm and chunky and the juices never bubbled up through pie vents. The pie crust also looked anemic.
  • Couldn’t the dough be divided in two before refrigerated?
  • Heed the recipe when it says to “gently apply” pressure when attaching the top crust. I had a “now what?” moment when I realized that it’s not the usual “folding the top crust over the bottom crust” routine.
  • I did like the technique of cutting those frozen butter cubes in the food processor with the flour. Little gravelly butter balls, I think my mistake was when I put the dough together… my food processor bowl was very small and most of the dough got “smooshed” together which destroyed those buttery layers.

7 thoughts on “2 days to apple pie …

  1. I’ve been following your tweets about this particular pie crust and have been dying to hear how it turned out. It’s amazingly long recipe for pie crust. Kudos to you for trying it out. It may not have been perfect but I’ll bet it tasted good anyway!

  2. We live and learn, huh! The cool thing is you gave it a shot. I know Michel would be happy to hear that! Do you have another recipe in mind from his latest book? I can’t wait to find out!

  3. Thanks Sid!
    Thanks Rosa!
    Thanks El! I had high hopes for this recipe and the book as a whole…I just don’t get it. 😦 It did taste good as a lot of my guests said it was not too sweet. but it was a lot of work with not much in way of incredible results.
    You are right, Stephanie. I am glad I tried it. His book is a source of inspiration and ideas, nothing more. None of the recipes seem to work for me. I tried his microwave pastry cream but it tasted so much like corn starch and his marshmallow buttercream – ugh microwaved gelatin does not smell good and the whole thing curdled. so disappointed but at the same time it gave me ideas on how things could be done.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s